-
Contracts and Property LawIntroductionFormation of contracts is an activity that drives our daily lives, but something that wefrequently ignore. Whether buying a basket of groceries at the local grocery store orsigning a 5-year employment contract, we are forming legally binding and enforceablecontracts. If the product at the grocery store is incorrectly packaged and labeled, youcan return it for a refund. If your boss tells you that you are fired, you obviously need alawyer.The basic principle of contract law is that it derives from two sources: (1) common law,which is a body of law created by centuries of judicial decisions, and (2) the UniformCommercial Code, created in the 1940s. Typically, transactions involving real estateand services are governed by common law, and contracts for the sale of goods bymerchants are governed by the Uniform Commercial Code. We also look at property inthis lesson—real property involving land; tangible property, such as your watch; andintellectual property, such as a patent you develop and procure.ElementsofaContract:Offer,Acceptance,andConsiderationThere are three basic elements of contract formation. Offer: Must be conveyed directly from the offeror to the offeree, with sufficientdetails to enable and enforce an agreement. Acceptance: Offeree must accept the exact terms offered (in mirror image), andthe acceptance must be conveyed back to the offeror. Note that a counteroffer by theofferee terminates the original offer and it is no longer available for acceptance by theoriginal offeree. Consideration: Must include an exchange of something of value to each party;court will generally not rule on what is fair value, only that the parties agreed to theexchange.In addition to contracts requiring the three elements noted above, the courts recognizecertain defenses that serve to invalidate a contract.Typical defenses to contracts are
-
1. lack of capacity;2. duress;3. unconscionability;4. mistakes;5. illegality; and6. fraud.The list of six defenses above introduces a breed of contracts so unfair or unethical thatthe law simply will not enforce the agreement due to duress, fraud, andunconscionably.Contracts That Must Be in WritingCertain kinds of contracts must be in writing under the statute of frauds. The mostcommon example is that real estate contracts must be in writing to be valid. State lawstend to vary on the exact details of what is required in a contract for the sale of land.Other contracts that must be in writing include contracts to pay the debts of another person or organization; contracts that cannot be completed within 1 year; contracts involving the sale of goods for $500 or more; contracts in consideration of marriage (prenuptial agreements); and contracts to answer for the debts of another person.The exact requirement of the form of the writing of a contract is not specified. In theBasquiat case, the court found that a crayon writing on a napkin was enough to fulfill thewriting requirement of a contract for acquiring artwork for $3,000. In court, evidence tocounter the writing of a contract is not allowed under the parol (oral) evidence rule.Methods of Discharging a ContractWhen a contract is terminated, it is said to be discharged. The discharge of a contractcan occur by a number of different methods, including the following. Discharge by complete or substantial performance Discharge by mutual agreement of the parties to the contract Discharge by “conditions precedent and/or conditions subsequent” Discharge by impossibility of performance or commercial impracticability Discharge of contracts with various branches of the government under thesovereign acts doctrineEarly unwarranted discharge of a contract is referred to as a breach, and can becompensated by monetary damages or compensatory damages, nominal or liquidateddamages, or punitive damages if there is some degree of a tortuous interference.Global Dimensions of Contract Law
-
The rapid expansion of the global commercial world has led to a demand for contractualagreements to adapt to the needs of the international environment. The UniformComputer Information Transaction Act (UCITA) was instituted when it became apparentthat common law and the UCC could not monitor contracts on the international-Internetbasis. This led to e-contracts and e-signatures, and eventually the United Nationsadopted the UCITA noted above.DefinitionofLandandTypesofInterestorOwnership and UseReal property is defined as land and anythingconnected to it: fixtures, such as buildings, homes, and to a lesser extent, even thingslike ceiling cranes in a manufacturing building. The extent of ownership of real propertyalso extends to items like mineral rights. The various types of ownership interest includethe following. Fee simple: Complete and ultimate ownership through a deed. Conditional estate: Complete ownership, but subject to some type of condition forthe land’s use. Life estate: Complete ownership, but one that terminates upon the death of theowner. Future interest: The right to complete ownership based on some future event. Easement: The right to enter and utilize the land for some specific purpose (e.g.,install electric power lines across the back of your yard).Other issues that control property use and transfer of ownership include general warranty deeds; quitclaim deeds; adverse positions; condemnation; and zoning and other types of restrictive covenants.Global Dimensions of Property LawThere are major risks involved with an American citizen buying land in a foreign country.The laws concerning ownership of land vary greatly from one country to another.Further, a number of countries, including those of the European Union and Mexico,
-
have adverse restrictions on ownership of land by a person who or an organization thatis not a citizen of the country where the land is located. Further, American banks andmortgage companies generally will not fund the purchase of land in foreign countries.GovernmentClassificationandRegistrationofTypes of Intellectual PropertyIntellectual property is a dominant factor in today’s high-tech industrial world. In manycases, it is the difference between profitable operations and just churning out productswith little or no profit margin. The U.S. government formally recognizes protection ofintellectual property in the Constitution (Article 1, Section 8, Clause 8) and identifies fourtypes of intellectual property. Trademark: A distinctive mark, word, picture, and so on that represents anorganization or product and has been registered in every country where it is to beprotected. A trademark must be used, or the right for it to be protected will be lost. Patent: An exclusive right issued by the U.S. Patent Office to use a newlydeveloped product, process, invention, machine, and so on. The right to exclusive useis normally for a period of 20 years, and the originator can bring legal action to preventillegal use by another party. Copyright: The right to exclusive ownership of writing or artistry, which is valid forthe life of the author plus 70 years. The copyright is generated automatically uponproduction of the item, but in order to bring legal action to protect one’s copyright, itmust be registered at the U.S. Patent and Copyright Office. Trade secret: A process, method of operation, or compilation of information thatis not known to the public. It must bestow a competitive advantage to its owner ororiginator. A trade secret does not require registration with the government.GlobalDimensionsofIntellectualPropertyLaw:PatentsandCopyrightProtection,Plagiarism,andMoreThe major treaty protecting intellectual property through the international arena is theAgreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS), asnegotiated in the Uruguay round of negotiation (1986–1994) and administered by theWorld Trade Organization (WTO).